What High-Stakes Fiction Teaches Us About the Choices We Make

by | Insights

Have you ever revisited a major decision and asked, “What would have happened if I’d gone the other way?”

Two dark, unsettling stories — Ballad of a Small Player and The Man in the High Castle — push that question further: what if you were forced to watch the person you could have been, from inside the wreckage of the choices that got you here?

In Ballad of a Small Player, Colin Farrell plays “Lord Doyle,” running from a massive fraud and losing himself at Macau’s baccarat tables — a man haunting his own life, betting that one more win might buy back his salvation.

The takeaway: the wrong choice almost never announces itself. It shows up disguised as a shortcut, a small ethical bend, a risk you’ve already talked yourself into. Build an identity on top of that, and eventually you’re just going through the motions, stuck inside a loop you built yourself.

In The Man in the High Castle, Rufus Sewell’s John Smith spends decades convincing himself he served a brutal regime to keep his family safe — that there was never really a choice to make. Then a doorway into another world shows him a version of himself where the Allies won the war, and he sees the father he might have become: loving, principled, whole. It breaks him. He’s traveled too far down the other road to find his way back.

The takeaway: “I had no choice” might be the most dangerous sentence in leadership. Every time you trade your values for short-term safety, you’re quietly killing off a better version of yourself.

You don’t need a portal into another timeline to audit your own choices. A few things worth checking instead:

→ Watch for the slow pivot. A wrong turn is almost never a single dramatic moment — it’s small daily concessions that gradually redraw the map.
→ Try the mirror test. Would you recognize the person you originally set out to become?
→ Claim the alternative while you still can. Course-correct while you still have the agency to do it.

We’re the sum of our decisions. Make sure the person you’re building right now is someone you’ll be glad to look back on.

Where do you draw the line when a shortcut is staring you in the face? I’d like to hear how you think about it.

Create Your Best World

Evidence-based tools for self-awareness, emotional regulation, and identity change

Observe. Refine. Elevate.